Archives
This section contains previous Home page articles and other non-current documents
August 6, 2009 *** FOR Immediate RELEASE *** Unprecedented Coalition Opposes Narrow Nelson Aggregate License Application Burlington, ON (August 6, 2009)—An unprecedented coalition of community organizations has rallied in support of the City of Burlington and a Motion to require Nelson Aggregate to update its license application to open a new quarry before proceeding to hearing. Coalition members include Protecting Escarpment Rural Land (PERL), Environmental Defence, Lake Ontario Waterkeeper and the Coalition on the Niagara Escarpment. Burlington’s Motion heard in late July is also supported by Halton Region, the Halton Region Conservation Authority and the Niagara Escarpment Commission. Nelson Aggregate outright opposes it. “The application process is still in its early stages, a date for the hearing hasn’t even been set. This is the perfect opportunity, and with good reason, to get important environmental approvals in place and update the application,” said Roger Goulet, Executive Director of PERL. “Nelson Aggregate has adjusted this project several times. I don’t see how adjusting the approvals regime in the license application isn’t in the best interest of the community and long term decision making on the Niagara Escarpment.” “Nelson is not only proposing to open a new quarry, but to process the new aggregate on the old quarry site. This will significantly delay the rehabilitation of the 600-acre industrial site, which has been operating since 1953,” says Sarah Harmer, Co-Founder of PERL. “PERL and the coalition agree with the City, it’s just common sense. This hearing should be about one integrated site, with a comprehensive set of regulations and standards.” Nelson Aggregate prefers its project to be assessed under outdated policies, some over a decade old such as the 1997 Provincial Policy Statement, instead of the 2005 version. The City of Burlington contends the license application is incomplete, the issues for the hearing are scoped improperly and that a number of outstanding permit approvals (such as the Ontario Water Resources Act, Environmental Protection Act and Federal Fisheries Act) must be included in the application prior to the hearing. If not, the result may be a lengthy and possibly incomplete hearing or costly appeals process. And with local Council adopting a Motion on March 9th, 2009 stating that “no party spends valuable resources or wastes precious time addressing incomplete policies or standards”, there is even greater cause to update the application. As Harmer said, ‘it’s just common sense’. Nelson also filed a request for Costs against the Parties to the three-day Motion hearing, but did not address the Board. A decision in the complex Motion is expected by the end of summer.
*** For more information or to arrange interviews, please contact: Jennifer Foulds | Environmental Defence | (416) 323-9521 ext. 232 (office) | (647) 280-9521 (cell)Roger Goulet | Protecting Escarpment Rural Land | (905) 335-4219
About PERLPERL is involved in a number of initiatives to help protect the Niagara Escarpment for future generations. By far the biggest threat to the ongoing viability of the ecosystems and cultural heritage on the MT Nemo Plateau is a proposal to open a new 150 acre (82 hectare) open pit mine south of the existing 600 acre quarry. PERL retained Order of Canada architect Douglas Cardinal to help it devise a “Vision for Mount Nemo” that would allow Nemo’s industrial past to be transformed into a sustainable, ecological future. About Environmental Defence (www.environmentladefence.ca) Environmental Defence protects the environment and human health. We research solutions. We educate. We go to court when we have to. All in order to ensure clean air, clean water and thriving ecosystems nationwide, and to bring a halt to Canada's contribution to climate change.
National Post Reports ..... Sarah Harmer 1 - Lafarge 0
See full story
February 13, 2009
** FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE**
Tough Report on Nelson Aggregate
Quarry Application Cheered
Burlington quarry application is unacceptable
Please see our news Section at the link below for a related story
Breaking NEWS: JART REPORTS Transplanted Endangered Butternut Trees DEAD
PERL Starting to formulate it's NEW VISION FOR MT NEMO See link for more info.
Burlington--Ontario citizens, environmental organizations, and residents are reassured by the release this week of the multi-agency Joint Agency Review Team (“JART”) Report that science and good planning will stop the proposed quarry. JART experts from the City of Burlington, Halton Region, Niagara Escarpment Commission, Conservation Halton and Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources spent over 4 years reviewing the Nelson Aggregate Burlington quarry application and technical studies.
The consensus report highlights major, inherent problems in the 150-acre Nelson Aggregate Burlington quarry proposal.“The JART report is unmistakable in its negative assessment of this quarry application,” said Sarah Harmer, a Co-Founder of the Burlington citizens’ group Protecting Escarpment Rural Land (“PERL”). “As the existing 50 year-old quarry winds down operations in the next few years, it is time for an exit strategy and a new, ecologically sustainable vision for Mount Nemo”, she added.“PERL is very pleased that government experts have clearly expressed the inappropriateness of the Mount Nemo location for a below water table quarry”, said Roger Goulet, PERL’s Executive Director and a local resident. “Improving quality of life, the natural environment, and developing educational and ecologically sensitive uses of the former industrial site can create job opportunities, eco-tourism, and launch a new beginning for this fountainhead atop the Niagara Escarpment”, he added.
The JART Report also highlights issues surrounding consultation with First Nations, regarding a 1600’s longhouse village settlement and thousands of artifacts unearthed on site. PERL’s lawyer David Donnelly filed a submission calling for further review of the company’s First Nations consultation program, thoroughness of bone fragment analysis and historical significance of village site.
A few of the highlights of the JART Report: “JART concludes that the Nelson application does not adequately address the policies of the Niagara Escarpment Plan.” Pg 7
“The application does not meet portions of the Niagara Escarpment Plan, Region of Halton, and City of Burlington Official Plans.” Pg 5
“The proposed footprint would include extraction in significant woodlands and a provincially significant wetland” Pg 5 (This is not allowed under the Provincial Policy Statement (PPS))
“The inadequacy of the buffers proposed (for Provincially Significant Wetlands) is contrary to the Provincial Policy Statement.” Pg 9
“Nelson has not demonstrated to JART’s satisfaction that there will be no unacceptable impacts on streams and water supplies”. Pg 7
“Owing to the central location on the Mount Nemo Plateau, both the proposed quarry and the existing quarry present challenges with respect to the protection of headwater wetlands and watercourses which originate on the plateau. Further, the connectivity of the natural features and functions across the plateau is a critical component of natural heritage systems planning. The proposed extraction footprint will compromise these features and linkages.” Pg 9
“With respect to wells and hydrogeology, questions around lake filling, wetland protection, the impacts on private wells (water quality and quantity) remain.” Pg 5
PERL’s submissions to the JART in January 2009 highlighted the need to: (1) harmonize the Niagara Escarpment Plan with the Greenbelt Plan in advance of the Joint Board hearing, starting with updating the land designations on Mount Nemo, as recommended in the JART Report; (2) design and implement a Natural Heritage System for Mount Nemo after consultation with PERL and other stakeholders; and, (3) review the archaeological assessment and bone analysis of a 400 year-old First Nations village discovered on site.
The quarry review process assesses the application against a 24 year-old Niagara Escarpment Plan. “Making permanent land use changes to Mount Nemo using the outdated Niagara Escarpment Plan is like trying to fix a hybrid car using a 1985 repair manual”, said David Donnelly, counsel to PERL and Environmental Defence. “Halton Region needs to spend 52 cents on a letter to the province asking for an updated Niagara Escarpment Plan that’s finally Harmonized with the Greenbelt, before we spend millions on a hearing no one except the developer really wants”, Donnelly added.
The JART Report goes to a public meeting in Halton Region at Kilbride Public School,February 19, 2009. - 30 -
Contact: David Donnelly (416) 722-0220 Sarah Harmer (416) 461-4454
For Immediate Release Feb 3, 2009
URGENT: Attend this crucial meeting on the Mount Nemo Quarry application
After 4 years of study, the government Joint Agency Review Team (JART) is presenting its Report on Nelson Aggregate's quarry application. Experts have confirmed that this quarry proposal is poorly conceived and poses significant risk to our well water, our health and the health of our environment. You can help defeat this application.
Why should you care about this massive quarry application?
Nelson Aggregate/LaFarge has proposed a new 140-acre quarry on the Niagara Escarpment's sensitive Mount Nemo in North Burlington that is:
Part of the Provincially Significant Grindstone Creek Headwater Wetland Complex
Headwaters of Bronte, Grindstone, Tuck, Shoreacres, Appleby, Mount Nemo, Willoughby & Lowville Creek Systems
Home to rich biodiversity - Threatened Jefferson Salamander and Endangered Butternut Tree species
Nelson Aggregate/LaFarge is proposing to:
Blast below the water table risking major groundwater decline and negative impact on hundreds of domestic wells
Destroy up to 75,000 coniferous trees that provide clean air and offset harmful CO2 emissions
Destroy Provincially Significant Wetlands and Significant Old Growth Carolinian Forests
Continue to emit dust and conduct major blasting in a community which has already endured 55 years of open pit mining
What will happen at this meeting?
JART will present its report outlining its findings. You can question the experts and let JART know how you feel about this application by speaking out at this meeting.
“I couldn’t imagine a worse place to put a below-water-table quarry.” Senior water scientist Wilf Ruland
JART Public Meeting
February 19, 2009 6 – 9 pm JART presentation at 7 pm
Kilbride Public School Auditorium
You can get the JART report online after Feb 9
at http://cms.burlington.ca/Page167.aspx
We still strongly recommend that you attend the meeting so that you can hear the JART presentation and benefit from the subsequent Q & A.
====================================================
For Immediate Release Jan 30, 2009
Perl Hydrogeologist responds to comments regarding his review of proponents latest report
In the most recent in a series of responses and counter responses, Ray Blackport continues to find significant issues with the conclusions reached by Nelson Aggregates consultants. For a detailed technical account, see the link below.
http://www.perlofburlington.org/docs/Blackprt012009.pdf
Or Go to the Reports and Submissions page of this site.
====================================================
For Immediate Release November 20, 2008
New Niagara Escarpment Quarry Proposal Headed to Ontario Municipal Board
Government and environmental groups call referral to OMB “premature” and risky
Burlington, ON—Nelson Aggregate/ LaFarge has prematurely triggered a hearing in front of the Environmental Review Tribunal and the Ontario Municipal Board (called the ‘Joint Board’), forcing environmental groups, the Provincial Ministry of Natural Resources, the Niagara Escarpment Commission, Halton Region and the City of Burlington to now face a December 8, 2008 pre-hearing conference. Unless the McGuinty government stops this unnecessary process, a hearing could start as early as spring 2009.
Nelson Aggregate /LaFarge is proposing a new quarry be situated in the heart of Mount Nemo, a significant landform in North Burlington on the Niagara Escarpment and in Ontario’s Greenbelt. Mount Nemo is a unique geological feature. As a plateau, it sits above the landscape and relies solely on rainwater to supply an aquifer vital to hundreds of families and businesses on well water. It is a source water recharge area with over 20 tributaries originating on top of it and along its slopes. It is also habitat of Threatened and Endangered species such as the Butternut Tree and Jefferson Salamander, which Nelson/LaFarge is seeking to remove.
“We are very anxious that the protection of Mount Nemo not be shunted to a risky and grossly expensive process when the majority of the public and their democratically elected governments in the area support outright protection,” said Sarah Harmer, co-founder of Protecting Escarpment Rural Land (PERL).
Conservative estimates of the budgets required to fight the case at the Ontario Municipal Board and Environmental Review Tribunal are in the millions of dollars for what could be a six month hearing.
In May 2006 and again in April 2008, the Ministry of Natural Resources, the Niagara Escarpment Commission, Conservation Halton, the Region of Halton, and the City of Burlington all objected to Nelson Aggregate’s request for license approval under the Aggregate Resources Act, stating that such a request is premature. Chief amongst these concerns is that the Joint Agency Review Team, a government review process, has not finished its work reviewing the proposal. The hearing could proceed before this work is completed.
PERL has identified several critical matters like source water and species protection that the McGuinty government should address before the public be forced to squander precious time and resources fighting the proposed 150-acre quarry. Mount Nemo has endured over 50 years of aggregate extraction from a 640-acre Nelson Aggregate quarry that is now nearly exhausted.
PERL and Resterra Strategies recently invited Order of Canada architect Douglas Cardinal to Burlington to participate in creating a vision for a naturalized future for Mount Nemo and North Burlington as an alternative to more blasting and gravel trucks. Cardinal called for the Mount Nemo Headwaters Natural Heritage System to be completed before any new industrial activity is proposed for the area.
“Ontario residents expect that the McGuinty government will intervene and stay the Joint Board until the most sensitive features of the Niagara Escarpment have been protected,” said Dr. Rick Smith, Executive Director of Environmental Defence, a key member of the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance. “It is unconscionable that the last mapping and protection of wetlands, headwaters and threatened species on the Escarpment hasn’t occurred since Pierre Trudeau was Prime Minister. That’s embarrassing.”
PERL met last week to consider whether a boycott of the hearing is necessary in light of the recent OMB case involving a developer seeking an unprecedented $3.2 million cost award against a citizens’ group and PERL’s lawyer David Donnelly in the Big Bay Point matter.
YES - It's here again at LAST!
The Third Annual Benefit Concert Featuring
GREAT BIG SEA
Sarah Harmer
With special guest appearance by
Dr David Suzuki
and Jeremy Fisher

Hosted by Matt Hayes, CHCH TV and KLite FM radio personality
Sunday, September 27, 2009
I Love the Escarpment Too with Great Big Sea, Sarah Harmer and Dr David Suzuki, is an intimate outdoor concert and fun event. Get inspired to help save Mt Nemo - come and listen to words of wisdom and fantastic music. With a live auction, great food and beverages and a few other surprises, this event promises to be our best ever.
Date: Sunday, September 27th, 2 pm to dusk - Gates open at 1 pm
Place: The Johnston Farm in north Burlington
Price: Adults - $160 tax included
Children (13 and under) - $55 tax included
With tax receipt for adult tickets this is about the same price as last year!
Live and silent auctions , draws and more - please bring your cheque books!
Outdoor event - rain or shine - dress for the weather and feel free to bring a lawn chair
Get your tickets now - attendance is limited!
Purchase online at MapleMusic.com at http://www.maplemusic.com/product.asp?dept%5Fid=62&pf%5Fid=1330%2D47〈=EN
Or visit one of our local retailers to buy tickets (cheque or cash only):
Hikers Haven - Europe Bound, 166 South Service Road East, Oakville - 905-849-8928
A Different Drummer books, 513 Locust Street, Burlington - 905-639-0925
Pat's Party Rentals, 4080 Fairview St. Burlington (905-333-3034) and 448 Speers Rd. Oakville (905-845-8301)
Tell everyone you know that cares about clean water, fresh air and habitat for wildlife.
Get more information on PERL at www.perlofburlington.org.
Got questions? Contact us at perl@perlofburlington.org.
Brought to you by PERL Protecting Escarpment Rural Land www.perlofburlington.org and Escarpment Biosphere Conservancy www.escarpment.ca.
Sponsored by:
www.letslandscape.ca
www.millcroftfitness.com
www.mec.ca

www.vespaburlington.com
PERL Concert event a great success! A big THANK YOU to all for your generous support!
For a slide show of this years event courtesy of Pat's Party Rentals click here!
BREAKING NEWS:
PERL Concert a sellout!! Read the glowing reviews here!
Five time '08 Juno winner - Leslie Feist will sing at Sept 20th PERL event!! For the full story click here!
An intimate and interactive concert event at the top of Mt Nemo. Don't miss the concert event of the year in Burlington! This is a limited engagement event.
Ticket Information for 2nd Annual Benefit Concert Featuring Bruce Cockburn, Sarah Harmer and 2008 Juno Winner Derek Miller
Tickets may be purchased from the following vendors:
-
Hiker's Haven, 166 South Service Rd. E., Oakville
-
A Different Drummer Books, 513 Locust St. Burlington
-
Pat's Party Rentals, 4080 Fairview St. Burlington and 448 Speers Rd. Oakville
Online Purchase available through Maple Music: http://www.maplemusic.com/product.asp?dept%5Fid=1331&pf%5Fid=1330%2D38&lang=EN
** FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE **
August 11th, 2008
Burlington Hosts 2nd Annual Benefit Concert Featuring Bruce Cockburn, Sarah Harmer and 2008 Juno Winner Derek Miller.
Burlington—Local environmental group PERL (Protecting Escarpment Rural Land) announced plans for its second annual benefit concert, "I Love The Escarpment, Too!", for September 20, 2008.
Canadian music icons Bruce Cockburn and Sarah Harmer will headline the event, bringing their passion and music to help protect the land of the Niagara Escarpment. The Niagara Escarpment, a UNESCO World Biosphere Reserve and the jewel of Ontario's Greenbelt, is threatened by industrial development. PERL states: "We need everyone's help to save the water and amazing natural habitats of the Escarpment. This is a celebration of the people working to save the greenbelt across the province but it's also a call to action — we want the residents and the politicians to see that the Escarpment is worth fighting for."
This intimate outdoor concert will be a wonderful opportunity for the people of Southern Ontario who appreciate the ecological importance, and enjoy the beauty of the Niagara Escarpment — hiking, biking, camping, and farming — to get informed about the risks posed by destructive and inappropriate below water table industrial activity, and help protect it for generations to come. Proceeds from the concert will support for PERL's ongoing campaign to halt Nelson/Lafarge's new quarry application on Mount Nemo.
The outdoor afternoon concert will take place from 2-6pm at a local farm donated for the event, on Mount Nemo in North Burlington. There will be food and a cash bar available on the grounds. "I Love the Escarpment, Too!" Benefit Concert Featuring Bruce Cockburn, Sarah Harmer, and 2008 Juno winner Derek Miller. When: Saturday, September 20th 2-6pm Tickets are $99 for adults and $49 for children under 13 (tax not included). Tickets available online at www.maplemusic.com and local ticket retailers.
For more details and a complete list of retailers check out http://www.perlofburlington.org//
About PERL Protecting Escarpment Rural Land (PERL) is a citizens group dedicated to sustainability, quality of life, and the protection of the Niagara Escarpment, a UNESCO World Biosphere Reserve. Based in Burlington, Ontario, PERL and its team of experts has been carefully reviewing and commenting on an application for a proposed below water table quarry on the sensitive Mount Nemo plateau on the Niagara Escarpment in Burlington.
Contact Liz Walker Communications Volunteer PERL – Protecting Escarpment Rural Land Tel: 416-535-6378 Email: elizawalker@gmail.com www.perlofburlington.org info@perlofburlington.org
--------------------------------------------------
Sarah Harmer 1, Lafarge cement O
National Post
February 19, 2009, 10:54 AM
Peter Kuitenbrouwer
Folk singer Sarah Harmer calls Kingston home, but hasn't forgotten her roots on the Niagara Escarpment, where she grew up on the family farm, north of Burlington on the wonderfully-named Mount Nemo. Of late Ms. Harmer is lending her name and her support to a <http://perlofburlington.org/> fight locals, including her parents, are waging against a plan for <http://www.lafargenorthamerica.com/wps/portal/> Lafarge to expand its yawning Nelson Aggregate quarry that extracts gravel and rock from the escarpment on the mountain.
Today the Joint Agency Review Team presents its technical report on the proposed quarry expansion, at nearby Kilbride Public School. The report, four years in the making, appears to lean against the idea. "The Nelson application does not adequately address the policies of the Niagara Escarpment Plan," the authors write, adding, "The proposed footprint would include extraction in significant woodlands and a provincially significant wetland."
Ms. Harmer spent a few days fighting for the escarpment at her parents' 100-acre farm this week, where the house shakes violently on Thursdays at 3 p.m. when Lafarge is blasting. She says the battle against the quarry expansion is not won. "We want to be the first quarry application denied on the Niagara escarpment, but it's not a slam dunk, even though it's a world biosphere reserve," she says. "The science is saying, 'bad idea.' If science and good planning rule the day here, the quarry won't happen.' We must protect our water and our natural heritage long before we protect our parking lots.'" Lafarge's spokeswoman, whose office is in Virginia, did not immediately return a phone call.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Mass migrations and war: Dire climate scenario
By CHARLES J. HANLEY, AP Special Correspondent
CAPE TOWN, South Africa - If we don't deal with climate change decisively, "what we're talking about then is extended world war," the eminent economist said.
His audience Saturday, small and elite, had been stranded here by bad weather and were talking climate. They couldn't do much about the one, but the other was squarely in their hands. And so, Lord Nicholas Stern was telling them, was the potential for mass migrations setting off mass conflict.
"Somehow we have to explain to people just how worrying that is," the British economic thinker said.
Stern, author of a major British government report detailing the cost of climate change, was one of a select group of two dozen - environment ministers, climate negotiators and experts from 16 nations - scheduled to fly to Antarctica to learn firsthand how global warming might melt its ice into the sea, raising ocean levels worldwide.
Their midnight flight was scrubbed on Friday and Saturday because of high winds on the southernmost continent, 3,000 miles from here. While waiting at their Cape Town hotel for the gusts to ease down south, chief sponsor Erik Solheim, Norway's environment minister, improvised with group exchanges over coffee and wine about the future of the planet.
"International diplomacy is all about personal relations," Solheim said. "The more people know each other, the less likely there will be misunderstandings."
Understandings will be vital in this "year of climate," as the world's nations and their negotiators count down toward a U.N. climate conference in Copenhagen in December, target date for concluding a grand new deal to replace the Kyoto Protocol - the 1997 agreement, expiring in 2012, to reduce carbon dioxide and other global-warming emissions by industrial nations.
Solheim drew together key players for the planned brief visit to Norway's Troll Research Station in East Antarctica.
Trying on polar outfits for size on Friday were China's chief climate negotiator Xie Zhenhua, veteran U.S. climate envoy Dan Reifsnyder, and environment ministers Hilary Benn of Britain and Carlos Minc Baumfeld of Brazil.
Later, at dinner, the heavyweights heard from smaller nations about the trials they face as warming disrupts climate, turns some regions drier, threatens food production in poor African nations.
Jose Endundo, environment minister of the Democratic Republic of Congo, said he recently visited huge Lake Victoria in nearby Uganda, at 80,000 square kilometers (31,000 square miles) a vital source for the Nile River, and learned the lake level had dropped 3 meters (10 feet) in the past six years - a loss blamed in part on warmer temperatures and diminishing rains.
In the face of such threats, "the rich countries have to give us a helping hand," the African minister said.
But it was Stern, former chief World Bank economist, who on Saturday laid out a case to his stranded companions in sobering PowerPoint detail.
If the world's nations act responsibly, Stern said, they will achieve "zero-carbon" electricity production and zero-carbon road transport by 2050 - by replacing coal power plants with wind, solar or other energy sources that emit no carbon dioxide, and fossil fuel-burning vehicles with cars running on electric or other "clean" energy.
Then warming could be contained to a 2-degree-Celsius (3.4-degree-Fahrenheit) rise this century, he said.
But if negotiators falter, if emissions reductions are not made soon and deep, the severe climate shifts and sea-level rises projected by scientists would be "disastrous."
It would "transform where people can live," Stern said. "People would move on a massive scale. Hundreds of millions, probably billions of people would have to move if you talk about 4-, 5-, 6-degree increases" - 7 to 10 degrees Fahrenheit. And that would mean extended global conflict, "because there's no way the world can handle that kind of population move in the time period in which it would take place."
Melting ice, rising seas, dwindling lakes and war - the stranded ministers had a lot to consider. But many worried, too, that the current global economic crisis will keep governments from transforming carbon-dependent economies just now. For them, Stern offered a vision of working today on energy-efficient economies that would be more "sustainable" in the future.
"The unemployed builders of Europe should be insulating all the houses of Europe," he said.
After he spoke, Norwegian organizers announced that the forecast looked good for Stern and the rest to fly south on Sunday to further ponder the future while meeting with scientists in the forbidding vastness of Antarctica.
Sunday Oct 5th, 2008
PERL says THANK YOU!
To all the fantastic entertainers, their support staff and management, our sponsors, donors and the amazing volunteers - and most of all everyone who attended our event and who made I love the Escarpment Too 2008' the amazing success that it was!
On behalf of the PERL executive committee - We thank you!!!
Monday Sept 22nd, 2008
Mount Nemo rocks
Sarah Harmer and friends step up for the Escarpment
September 22, 2008
Graham Rockingham
The Hamilton Spectator
(Sep 22, 2008)
Benefit concerts aren't the kind of places that artists use to try out new songs. They usually just walk through a few tried and true numbers appropriate to the cause, thank the crowd and join the party backstage. But Sarah Harmer had a point to prove.
Her fans were starting to wonder if maybe she was spending too much time saving the world -- or at least a little piece of it in north Burlington called Mount Nemo -- and not enough time writing music for her next album.
So there couldn't have been a more appropriate place for Harmer to introduce two new songs than at a benefit concert Saturday afternoon atop Mount Nemo for PERL (Protecting Escarpment Rural Land) the environmental group she co-founded.
She didn't spend a lot of time introducing the new songs. She just slid them into her set. Two typical Harmer songs: The first, Late Bloomer, a mystery narrative of deceit and detection; the second, If I Only Had One Match Left, a coquettish little ditty about (excuse the pun) hot love.
On a sunny afternoon of great outdoor music from Harmer, Leslie Feist, Bruce Cockburn and Derek Miller, these two songs stood out. They showed that Harmer, one of the sweetest voices in Canadian music, has another finely crafted CD waiting for completion just as soon as she finishes battling the corporate forces aiming to blow another quarry out of Mount Nemo, the panoramic bump of escarpment land where she was raised.
Feist has the buzz that comes with five Juno wins and four Grammy nominations. And Cockburn has all the respect that 35 years of master musicianship brings. But this was Harmer's show, and most of the 750 people who paid $99 each for the privilege of attending this intimate show knew it.
The concert was staged with style on a private farm, located within walking distance of the Nelson Aggregate quarry. A canvas canopy provided some shade in front of the stage for half the well-heeled crowd, the rest relaxed on lawn chairs around the perimeter. Metalworks provided the sound. It was perfect.
More than 30 PERL volunteers poured beer and wine, as well as serving up burgers, dogs and homemade ice cream (Mount Nemo honey and Collingwood berries), while horses grazed directly behind the food tent.
With a ragged straw hat protecting her head from the sun, Feist mingled with the crowd, signing autographs and getting her picture taken with bright-eyed children (tickets were just $49 for 12-and-unders).
Shortly after 2 p.m., two-time Juno award winner Derek Miller and his band kicked off the show with a 45-minute set of vintage blues rock. Then came Harmer and her band with a 10-song set, heavy on lyrical melody and mercifully light on environmental politics.
Feist, the guest star who ensured the show would be a sell-out, took the stage for a brief set that included hits like Mushaboom and So Sorry. Backed only by a guitarist, the setting emphasized her uniquely delicate vocal phrasing.
Cockburn, looking like an old Zen master, added his own 40-minute solo set, delivering an acoustic guitar showcase with the instrumental Where All The Rivers End. He pulled out some old favourites like Tokyo and Wondering Where The Lions Are, as well as some eco-appropriate songs like If A Tree Falls and Beautiful Creatures.
Then Harmer and her band reclaimed the stage for a five-song finale with Cockburn and Feist, playing Cockburn's Lovers In A Dangerous Time and Waiting For A Miracle, and Harmer's Escarpment Blues and Deep In The Valley before ending the four-hour show with an intriguing take on Neil Young's Lotta Love. This was the second I Love The Escarpment, Too benefit. Last year, the Barenaked Ladies brought a smaller crowd to the same farm. It, too, was a great show.
It's possible the quarry application will be resolved sometime next year at the Ontario Municipal Board, which may or may not eliminate the need for these benefits.
Win or lose the quarry fight, let's hope Harmer keeps the Mount Nemo musical tradition alive.
grockingham@thespec.com
905-526-3331
Sunday Sept 21st, 2008:
Sunday Sept 7th, 2008:
Burlingtongreen voices support for Mt Nemo Natural heritage system
See BurlingtonGreens website for their letter in support of PERL's idea to create a natural heritage system for Mt Nemo.
March 24 - Objector responses,
required by April 4th!!
See the first link below for a sample response letter to Nelson Aggregates response to your objections. We encourage all to read the letter we sent to the community below these links for full instructions on what to do and where to send your letters.
The second link contains a list of issues and concerns for reference in writing your letter of continued objection. For those who copied PERL on your initial letter and for immediate members of the community, you should receive a package from PERL by mail in the next few days.
SEE SAMPLE LETTER, ISSUES LIST and the COMMUNITY LETTER below
Sample Letter: Sample letter in Word Format - Sample Letter in plain text format
Click here for Key contacts to send your letters to.
Issues list: www.perlofburlington.org/Issues.html
The chart below will help you to understand
the Aggregate Resources Act process and why it's so important to register your
continued objections to this proposal within the next few days
ARA Process Flow Chart: www.perlofburlington.org/ARAflow.pdf
The following letter was sent to all objectors and the public in the general Mt Nemo area.
Hello,
We at PERL are writing to let you know about an important decision
you need to make regarding your objections to the Nelson Aggregate application for a quarry on Mount Nemo in Burlington Ontario.
In of 2006 you sent a letter to Nelson Aggregate and the Ministry of Natural Resources (MNR) stating your objections to the proposed quarry. By this time, you should have received a response to your objections from Nelson Aggregate. If you haven’t, please contact them at 905-335-5250 or 800-263-6320.
You have only 20 days to respond to Nelson Aggregate’s letter otherwise the Ministry of Natural Resources will consider that you have withdrawn your objections.
If you are not satisfied with Nelson’s response and continue to oppose this quarry proposal, we encourage you to send in a letter within 20 days and make your views known. We want to help by providing you with information and a sample letter which we have enclosed.
Your choices are:
1. Write your own letter expressing your concerns – feel free to reference any of the information we have provided to you in the attached Key Issues and Concerns document or from the PERL web
site.
2. Use the Sample Letter we have enclosed. Be sure to add this information to make the letter valid:
Print your name
Print your full mailing address
Sign and date the letter
In either case the MNR requires that you send two copies - one copy to the Ministry of Natural Resources (MNR) and one copy to Nelson Aggregate via Registered Mail or delivered in person.
We’d like to make this easier for you by suggesting that you send your two letters to PERL in the enclosed stamped envelope before March 25th and we’ll do our best to ensure that your letter gets to Nelson and the MNR on time.If you choose to send your letter via Registered Mail directly to Nelson and the MNR, we request that you send PERL a copy of your letter in the envelope provided. Be sure to get your letter to PERL, or directly to the MNR and Nelson, by the required date or your letter will not make the deadline and your objections will be withdrawn by the MNR and the MNR will assume that you no longer object to the proposed quarry.
Thank you in advance for your attention to this important matter. We hope you will respond to Nelson’s letter by objecting to their proposed quarry which could have devastating affects on drinking water sources, ancient forests, threatened and endangered species habitats, and the community that calls this area home.
Sincerely
PERL Executive
40572 Upper Brant Postal Outlet
Burlington, Ontario L7P 4W1 905-331-7189
http://www.perlofburlington.org//
Email: ara@perlofburlington.org
Posted: March 3, 2008
April 4th Deadline to Voice Objections!
For those who wrote letters of objection to the proposed quarry on Mt Nemo, your response from the company should have been received by now. The deadline for you to register your continued objection is fast approaching.
Keep in mind, you have 20 days from the receipt of your letter from Nelson to respond indicating the reasons for your continued objection to their proposal. In
the next few days we will be posting a number of documents to assist with that process.
Stay tuned!!
Posted: December 1, 2007
POWER Annual General Meeting
Halton Hills Cultural Centre and Library
See the attached Halton Compass article
More Info: http://www.perlofburlington.org/POWERAGM.jpg
Posted: November 28, 2007
New Lawn Sign Program Announced by PERL
As of this coming Monday, November 28th 2005, PERL lawn signs will be available. Show your support for this great cause by displaying one proudly on your front lawn!!!
To order yours, send an email to info@perlofburlington.org
To view what the sign will look like, see the link below.
More Info: www.perlofburlington.org/perlsign.pdf
Posted: November 13, 2007
Election Survey Results!
The results are in. See the link below to see how your candidate responded to PERL's survey on the environment. You can also visit our "Links" section to view/download this document in PDF format.
This document is best viewed using Microsoft Word. To navigate, click on the candidates name to see their comments or refer to the top (HOME) of the document for a summary of all candidates and their responses.
Tickets/More Info: 2006responses.doc
Posted: September 30th 2007
Transplanted butternut trees under stress
According to field reports, at least two of the endangered butternut trees that were transplanted are under extreme stress and likely will not survive. When asked whether this was a direct result of transplantation, PERL representatives would not comment. Saying only that it is their understanding that at least one of the trees was naturally occurring and therefore the width of it's root system would not be conducive to transplantation. In addition, the shallow nature of the initial transplantation likely did not help their future prospects. PERL's representative was saddened and troubled by this unfortunate incident.
Posted: September 29, 2007
Mt Nemo, ON: I Love the Escarpment TOO!!
As a follow-up to the great success of Sarah Harmers "I love the Escarpment" tour, promises to be another great event. Held at the Johnston Farm it will feature Barenaked Ladies and Sarah Harmer. September 29th, 2007 BURLINGTON, ON This is the first announcement of this very special and intimate show. We expect tickets to go quickly.
Please visit http://www.maplemusic.com/ for ticket info. $150 per person. 19+ event Hors d'oeuvres and refreshments will be provided with admission. All proceeds go to PERL's efforts to secure the healthy future of Mount Nemo's world class ecosystems, biodiversity and water resources.
More Info: http://www.maplemusic.com/product.asp?dept%5Fid=62&pf%5Fid=1330%2D31&lang=EN
Posted: September 2, 2007
PERL and Greenbelt Alliance Launch Green Gravel Initiaitve
For Immediate Release August 30, 2007
Pitfalls in Greenbelt Protection Unearthed
Provincial parties challenged to reform stone, sand and gravel legislation and adopt
North America’s first Green Standard for gravel
Toronto, Ontario – A new Greenbelt priorities paper, released today by the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance, highlights the environmental effects of aggregate extraction and makes the case for provincial reform of this unsustainable land use.
Aggregate extraction is essentially open pit min ing. With it, comes all kinds of ecological injustices, including threatening already endangered species, fragile forests and wetlands; taking massive amounts of drinking water; releasing harmful pollution to our air from thousands of truck jo urneys per day; and leaving permanently scarred landscapes.
All this is happening in and just beside Ontario’s protected Greenbelt , 1.8 millions acres of green space, farmland and natural areas in the Greater Golden Horseshoe
region. “You wouldn’t expect this kind of environmental devastation in the pride of Ontario – our Greenbelt,” said Dr. Rick Smith, Executive Director, Environmental Defence.
In response to the ever increasing numbers of proposed gravel pits and quarries which threaten the integrity of the Greenbelt, the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance has launched its Green Gravel Campaign with a new paper – Green Gravel: Prio rities for Aggregate Reform – directed to the provincial government and all political parties. Despite the Greenbelt designation, quarries continue to be proposed and approved in
environmentally significant areas including farmland, escarpment and moraine.
“The Green Gravel Campaign hopes to expose longstanding issues that have been kept under the radar of public consciousness,” said Sarah Harmer, Co-Chair, Protecting Escarpment Rural Land (P.E.R.L.). “In fact there are more than 25 pieces of legislation and policy that apply to aggregates extraction, and yet
there is little to prevent the Greenbelt from being trucked away one load at a time. It’s time to take a closer look at how the law is functioning.”
On top of the immediate impact of quarries on Greenbelt lands, there are other issues of concern that need addressing: the rights and interests of First Nations, climate change, protection of our water, and protection of viable farmland.
“Ontario has an opportunity to lead the way in setting a groundbreaking green standard for this industry,” said Penny Richardson, President, Coalition of Concerned Citizens (CCC).
In its priority paper, the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance makes several key recommendations:
1. Develop and put in place a long term conservation strategy for aggregates (stone, sand, gravel and
shale) – reduce, reuse, recycle .
2. Stop new aggregate extraction in the Greenbelt and abutting agricultural land.
3. Redesign licensing and permit approvals to make it fair to the public .
4. Develop effective mechanisms for operations and rehabilitation compliance – the industry currently monitors itself.
5. Address personal and environmental health concerns – carcinogenic dust and carbon dioxide.
“Aggregates are important to society, used in our homes, schools, hospitals, roads and transit,” said Graham Flint, Chair of Friends of Rural Communities and the Environment (FORCE). “But their extraction has inherently detrimental effects on our air, water, climate and quality of life. A finer balance needs to be struck.”
About the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance: The Ontario Greenbelt Alliance is a diverse multi-stakeholder coalition of more than 80 organizations who share a common vision for protecting and expanding the Golden Horseshoe Greenbelt. Environmental Defence is the coordinator of the Ontario Greenbelt Alliance. http://www.greenbelt.ca/.
For more information, or to arrange interviews, please contact:
Jennifer Foulds , Environmental Defence, (416) 323-9521 ext 232; (647) 280-9521 (cell)
Sarah Harmer, Co-Chair, P.E.R.L., (416) 461-4454
Penny Richardson, President, CCC (905) 838-2590
Graham Flint, Chair, FORCE, (905) 659-541
|